Do You Need to Remember Everything for EMDR Therapy?

Overhead photo of a woman lying down with curly hair, covering her face with both hands, surrounded by scattered Polaroid photos and two vintage instant cameras

Many people can say that something upsetting happened but cannot say exactly how it unfolded. The order of events may have blurred, certain conversations may be gone, and some details may never have been clear in the first place. If that describes you, it is reasonable to wonder whether EMDR is even an option.

EMDR does not require a complete verbal account of what happened. You can begin without telling the whole story, because treatment can focus on what you remember along with the ways the experience still shows up for you today.

What Can EMDR Focus On If Memories Are Incomplete?

EMDR is an evidence-based treatment for PTSD, and the 2023 VA/DoD clinical practice guideline strongly recommends it as a trauma-focused therapy. In my practice, I often use EMDR to work with distress connected to earlier experiences, including negative beliefs and emotional responses that may continue to affect how someone relates to themselves and others in the present.

When we consider what EMDR might focus on, we look at more than a memory itself. An experience you recall, even in part, may come with beliefs about yourself, such as “I am not safe” or “I am too much.” It may also come with emotions and physical sensations that can arise when you think about it. A present-day situation that stirs up the same distress can be just as relevant to treatment planning. What ends up as a focus of treatment is decided together, through assessment, and it does not have to include every one of these pieces.

Consider someone who remembers an earlier relationship marked by frequent conflict. They cannot recall every argument or the order things happened, yet certain moments in their current relationship, such as a partner going quiet after a disagreement, stir up familiar feelings. In therapy, we would start with those present-day reactions and whatever they do remember. If EMDR were being considered, we might explore whether a remembered interaction, or a present-day situation that triggers the distress, would be an appropriate focus. We would pay attention to the beliefs that go along with it, perhaps something like “I have to keep the peace or I will lose them,” and to the emotional and bodily responses that arise.

What Happens Before EMDR Processing Begins?

EMDR is a structured psychotherapy approach using bilateral stimulation, such as guided eye movements or tapping. While bilateral stimulation is often the most famous component of EMDR, a good deal of the work happens before that component is used.

Early sessions are mostly conversational history-gathering. We talk about what brought you in and what you hope will change. I ask about your background and the experiences that seem relevant, and I want to understand you within the broader context of your life. This stage is also where we begin building a reliable working relationship, which matters in EMDR just as it does in other approaches to therapy.

The preparation phase focuses on ways to manage distress that may come up during EMDR. Working with difficult experiences can bring up uncomfortable emotions or experiences, so we want to make sure you have strategies and resources available to navigate those reactions during and between sessions. 

As we learn more about your experiences and goals, we can begin identifying potential treatment targets. Following preparation, we assess the appropriate targets and determine together when to begin processing. How long preparation takes and how quickly we move depend on your individual needs and circumstances. Working with distressing experiences can be uncomfortable at times, which is why preparation and pacing are individualized.

How Do You Know Whether EMDR Is Right for You?

You do not have to arrive knowing exactly what you need. Many people begin with a general sense that something is hard, such as a pattern in their relationships or a reaction that seems larger than the situation.

We can begin with what you are experiencing now, what you hope will change, and whatever you do remember. From there, we can consider whether EMDR belongs in your treatment. Sometimes it does, and it can be integrated into the relational and attachment-informed individual therapy I offer. Other times, a different approach may be more appropriate, or additional assessment or preparation may be helpful.

Considering EMDR Therapy?

You don't need to have every detail of your experiences figured out before exploring whether EMDR might be helpful. Whether it fits is something we can explore together, starting from where you are now. You can learn more about my approach to EMDR therapy or reach out to talk it through.

Previous
Previous

What Does Codependency Look Like in a Relationship?